Forgive me, but I really need to fly through the rest of this because I can’t spend any more time looking back. It’s driving me crazy. I hope to one day look back on all of this and see what it is that I’m missing.
Here’s the Reader’s Digest version of the rest of the story:
We made changes.
People got mad.
Deb quit and left me in charge.
Now I’m quitting.
LOL!!!
Just kidding! Kinda…
O.K. Picking up where I left off…so, we took a survey of the women in our church. This is what we discovered (actually, we already suspected, but the survey gave us further proof):
56% of the women in our church have been attending less than 5 years.
62% of women feel like they have a weak to O.K. relationship with God.
63% of women don’t feel connected to other women in our church.
The largest struggles of women in our church are stress/anxiety followed closely by depression and loneliness.
We broke it down by age category and this is what we discovered (I hope you can read these):
This is our average “Generation X” woman:
This is our average “Baby Boomer” woman:
This is our average “Builder” woman:
So, now we are faced with the tough questions. What do we do about this?
- How do we help women feel more connected to God and connected to other women in our church?
- How do we create a safe place for women to thrive in intergenerational relationships?
- How do we reach out to women who are struggling with difficult life circumstances and/or strongholds (abuse, divorce, addictions, single parenthood, depression, broken relationships and infertility)?
- How are we drawing women into the church? Are we going to the community or are we expecting the community to come to us?
- Why are we doing what we’re doing and is the current ministry having a significant spiritual impact for women? (Tradition? Outreach?)
- Are women growing in their relationship with Jesus?
After much research, we decided that the best way to get women connected was through small groups. We envisioned a “hub” where women were coming together for Bible studies and prayer and, of course, coffee. Here is the original proposal we came up with (some of this material is from Beverly White Hislop’s book Shepherding a Woman’s Heart):
Just as people need food to keep their bodies healthy, so do Christian women need good spiritual food to stay healthy. A steady diet and nurturing climate that foster maturity and spiritual strength should form the foundation of our ministry to women. However, the menu selection should include items that keep in mind women that are young, hurting, or lost. We need to purposefully train women to use and sharpen their spiritual gifts so they can turn around and serve other women who could benefit from them. The goal of all these healthy meals should produce results. We do not want to see women getting fat and lazy (spiritually speaking, of course!). They need to be strengthened to go out and fulfill Christ’s mission for their life.
“Tuesday Morning Break”– Women’s small groups should be in line with all of New Hope Church’s small groups…with a twist. We could have two opportunities a week for women to attend a small group and get connected. The format would be as follows: Tuesday mornings…All women could come to the church. There will be excellent child care provided. Snacks will be provided. There will be a time of worship and announcements concerning upcoming New Hope events and New Hope ministries. We could have a guest speaker once a month during this time. We could have women sharing testimonies or devotions during this together time. We could have a drama team to do short “thought-provoking” dramas. We could also do communion during this time. Then after 30 minutes of “together” time, women would break up into their small groups. Each small group could be going over different topics. For example, one group could be doing a Beth Moore study, one group could be doing II Corinthians, one group could be doing a study on marriage or singleness, etc… There will be a time for New Hope women to connect and grow. There will also be the training time to teach New Hope women how to serve and share their faith. This same model can be done on a Thursday evening for those women who are unavailable to attend on Tuesday mornings because of jobs or other commitments. This small group ministry would be the singular focus of the Women’s Ministry at New Hope Church. This ministry should be drawing women into New Hope Church and other church ministries.
This was just an idea in our minds. We had other plans for outreach opportunities, worship opportunities, etc… but the small groups were the main focus of our women’s ministry extreme make-over. Why didn’t we have this in place before? After all, we were a church of around 750…you’d think this would’ve been done before. Ah…here comes the sticky part. We had a parachurch women’s Bible study meeting at our church at that time. They were doing a fine job of teaching women biblical knowledge. Why change? The main reason was that we have a different philosophy of ministry. We believe that women need more than just biblical knowledge to thrive in the life God gave them. The church is not about filling people’s brains with knowledge…it’s about radical life change. Can radical life change happen by Bible study? Yes. Of course. Is Bible study the only thing a Christian needs? No. Of course not.
I recently picked up Mark Driscoll’s book, Radical Reformission, and he says this about parachurch organizations, “…the failure of such ministries is that they are often disconnected from the local church, connecting unchurched people to Jesus without connecting them to the rest of Jesus’ people…they lack the benefits of a church culture in which all generations are integrated to help people navigate the transitions of life. This further separates families from each other if mom, dad, and kids are each involved in disconnected life-stage ministries outside of their church, rather than in integrated ministries within it.”
O.K. I’ve set the stage and introduced the players. I think you can imagine what happened next. We moved forward with the vision and stepped on some pretty pedicured toes. Can you hear Kramer saying, “C-C-C -Cat fight”? *canned laughter*
Here’s how it went down. I was in a women’s small group that was being led by my friend, Deb. Remember her? She was the new women’s ministry director at that time. Ironically, we were studying the book of Nehemiah and were pretty pumped up…knowing that God had called us to make some necessary changes. This was near the end of spring 2004. Josh and I were also in a small group together and some of the women in that group wanted to get together for a women’s Bible study for the summer. This was a perfect opportunity to get things started.
That summer, Deb’s group and my new group met together at the church. We hired some teenagers to watch our kids, made out a snack schedule and got together. We met together for snacks and coffee early in the morning and then our two groups broke up and went through a study. Our group went through Bad Girls of the Bible and Deb’s group went through a book of the Bible…I can’t remember which one. This worked out great for summertime. We pitched the idea of continuing on and adding more groups in the fall. Some of the girls liked the idea…others didn’t. They didn’t want us messing with their current system. I was a bit surprise, but…whatever.
We advertised and recruited and that fall we launched our first official session of Tuesday Morning Break. We had 6 groups and 49 women showed up. This was pretty exciting. I know that I benefited from it. I got to meet women that I never would’ve met before. We learned together, prayed together, ate together and had a good time. It was so refreshing to see women during the weekend services and have them ask how specific things were working out in my life and to hear that they had been praying for me throughout the week. They really cared. It was no longer a shallow-level how-are-you-I’m-fine kind of relationship. Women were getting real with each other. It was a small start, but a great start.
However…the bad news. All of a sudden there was a huge rift between the women in our church. There became an “us and them” competition kind of thing happening between us and the other Bible study that many of the women in our church attended. I’m not going to say anything else beyond that because I think I’m bordering the gossip boundary. The reason I mention the rift is because this was a very painful and discouraging time for me…and I suspect for Deb, too. We were misunderstood. We were told that we weren’t spiritually deep enough. We were told that our childcare wasn’t good enough. We were told that we were too young and immature to do this. We were told that we were ignoring the needs of the older women. We were asked to quit. But we kept on going. This drive was so deep within us that we had to continue on. Something (or Somebody) kept pushing us forward.
I want to fast-forward at this point. Last summer, Deb took a job in another town and their family moved. I was the obvious candidate as the new women’s ministry director and reluctantly took it on. After some prayer and review and conversations with the leadership team, we decided to cut the events and focus on Tuesday Morning Break and our annual women’s retreat. We almost cancelled the retreat. The reason we wanted to cut everything back was to get the women in our church connected to each other through small groups. We’ve since added outreach, but this mostly happens through the small groups. We have a wonderful lady come on the team who has a heart for the hurting in our community. She has coordinated a group of women to lead a Bible study at a teen girl’s recovery home. The stories that have come out of this have been amazing and we are looking forward to doing more of this. We had several other outreach opportunities throughout the past couple of terms…a Hurricane Katrina relief effort came from the small groups. I learned how to knit during one outreach opportunity. My women’s small group knit scarves for some poverty stricken children in our community. These are all great things that are happening…however, I tend not to focus on the good things. I think this is a fine balance that a lot of ministry leaders face.
Instead of celebrating the women who are thriving in this new community, I’m constantly asking, “Who is missing and why aren’t they connected? Why don’t they want to join us?”
I hear great testimonies all the time. I just had a woman tell me not to change a thing because she adores what is happening on Tuesday mornings. I hear women say this is the best thing for women that our church has ever done. We’ve grown and continue to grow. We had over 75 women show up last September…not counting the women who are connected to the other women’s group that meet at other times in the week. That’s about 20% of the women in our church and I can’t help but think about the 80% that are missing…and feel like a failure because I haven’t shared the vision with them to help them understand why we need them.
I have lost a lot of my enthusiasm and drive for this. Last fall I went into a deep depression. I had no energy or drive to do anything. Josh recognized that I had sunk into depression before I did. He came home one night and found me still in my pajamas playing computer games. I remember struggling to make some cornbread one night and it was from a box. All I had to do was add the egg and water and stir. It seemed like such a huge and overwhelming task for me. It was ridiculous.
During this time, I spent a lot of time talking with God and asking Him what was going on. I begged Him to give me a fresh vision and passion for the ministry to women at our church, or to raise somebody else up who could care for the spiritual well-being of the women…somebody who could take the ministry to the next level. The foundation has been poured, and now the builder needs to show up.
I’m done. I don’t have the fresh passion and vision. However, God hasn’t brought forth the next leader, yet. All of the women that are ideal in my mind are going through life crises right now. Where is she? Who is she? Am I missing the person God has chosen for this? I cannot continue on as the leader…I know this. But, I don’t feel as if I can quit right now, either.
I’ll share my fresh heartbreak next. Thanks for letting me share my story. I’m so glad to finally have it out. But, again…it’s after midnight and I need to quit blogging this late.